mobile payments banking

The 14th of September brings new rules for those of us who bank or shop online. Stronger regulations from the second Payment Services Directive mean that shoppers and those banking may be asked for additional layers of security when making transactions, with some experts even warning that a third of shopping transactions could fail under the rules.1


Consumer Intelligence data shows that customers are unlikely to welcome the intrusion, with most feeling that banking is secure enough already, and many already struggling to cope with layers of authentication including passwords, memorable information and security devices.

“Most customers are not aware of the new rules coming in, and our research shows that the efforts banks are making to inform them may need to be redoubled if there is not to be a shock next week, “ says Ian Hughes, CEO of Consumer Intelligence. “Banks must make this experience as simple as possible if customers are to remain satisfied through the changes.”


Customers in the Dark

Our research, conducted in early September shows that over 60 per cent of the population are not aware of the changes coming. Only 39 per cent of respondents said that they knew there was a security change, and a quarter of those who knew had found about it elsewhere, rather than received a letter from their bank.


Banks have been asking customers to update their security details in a minority of cases, with 57 per cent of people saying they had not been asked to change anything in recent weeks.

Chart 1: Changes that banks have asked their customers to make

No security changes 57%
Update security details 27%
Download an app 13%
Use a new device when you log on to your account or make a payment 10%
Take any other extra security steps 8%


“While some banks are being proactive, many customers have no idea that changes are ahead,” says Ian. If transactions are rejected or they can’t access their banking after the 14th it will come as a shock.”

Current security arrangements

Our survey shows that using a password is the most common way to login into online or mobile banking, although other forms of security including biometric steps such as fingerprint scanning or eye scans are becoming more common for those using their mobile phones for banking. Over a quarter are already using a security token for mobile banking, and 11 per cent for those banking online.

Chart 2: Security arrangements for both online and mobile banking - what security steps do customers have to take?

Mobile banking

Password 53%
Memorable information (such as mother’s maiden name, or name of pet) 32%
Fingerprint scan 30%
I don’t use mobile banking 26%
Use of security token or device 11%
Eye scan 9%


Online banking on a computer or similar device

Password 78%
Memorable information (such as mother’s maiden name, or name of pet) 58%
Use of security token or device 27%
I don't use online banking 9%


Most customers are happy with the current level of security their banks are offering. Nearly 70 per cent agreed with the statement ‘I feel online banking is secure’, while only a quarter agreed or strongly agreed with the statement ‘I wish my bank asked for more identification and passwords to make online banking more secure’.

A third of people agreed that they find it hard to remember the passwords and memorable information that is necessary to get into online banking.

As the chart below shows, overall satisfaction with current security measures is very high, with customers believing that online banking is more secure, on average, than making payments with a mobile phone.


Chart 3: How secure, on average, do people find the following (where five is very secure and one is not secure at all).

Login to mobile banking 4
Login to online banking 4.1
Making payments from a mobile phone 3.8
Viewing a balance and transactions online 4.1


“Customers are convinced that online banking is already secure, and many are struggling with existing needs for passwords and information,” warned Ian. “If extra security measures cause payments to be denied, or customers cannot get into their accounts, they will struggle to see the benefit. It’s vital that banks manage this change well for the sake of their relationship with their customers.”




[FREE REPORT] The Travel Money Market Today: When Digital Becomes Necessity

Consumer Intelligence's bi-annual travel money survey which gives you a snapshot of the market today, and while change in the travel money industry might seem slow, customers are gaining confidence in new methods and brands.


This edition contains data on how British holidaymakers spend while travelling. It reveals differences between generations and destinations, and a growing reliance on technology from British travellers spending abroad.


Download report


Submit a comment

You may also like

Are Foreign Exchange Consumers Being Treated Fairly At The ATM?
Are Foreign Exchange Consumers Being Treated Fairly At The ATM?
4 August, 2016

When banks are continuously under the microscope to treat foreign exchange consumers fairly and honestly, it seems rathe...

Banks, You Are Annoying Your Customers. Stop It!
Banks, You Are Annoying Your Customers. Stop It!
21 September, 2017

Never underestimate the power of low-level irritation. In the coming year, bank customers are going to have to put up wi...