Rarely do we see an event in UK General Insurance that so profoundly influences the consumer and the insurer equally. Yet, with the recent Ogden rate announcement, we find ourselves at such a crossroads, with both immediate and long-term implications for pricing, reserving, and overall market behaviour.
A brief historical backdrop
Appreciating the significance of this year’s rate change helps to recall the significant shifts we witnessed in 2016. Back then, an unexpected change triggered widespread disruption: premiums shot up to accommodate greater claims costs, and consumers responded by shopping around at levels not seen in years. Price comparison websites thrived in that climate, seizing what many viewed as a “golden era” of switching.
This time, however, the situation looks somewhat different. The market has had some early signals—most notably, the updates from Scotland and Northern Ireland, which use a similar methodology. Unlike in 2016, several brands factored the impending Ogden adjustment into their pricing much sooner, hoping to steady the ship in advance. As a result, we’re not expecting the same dramatic volatility in consumer premiums.
Consequences for pricing and reserving
From a purely technical standpoint, the higher Ogden rate should exert downward pressure on premiums. In practice, younger drivers—often the hardest hit by higher premiums—may benefit most swiftly. The effect on reserving is also positive: many carriers could find themselves able to release some of their existing claims provisions, translating into healthier combined operating ratios (COR). In short, we could liken it to a steadying breeze clearing storm clouds overhead—insurers see a path to improved solvency without the turbulence of significant capital strain.
The consumer lens and potential changes in behaviour
One of the key perspectives we champion at Consumer Intelligence is the consumer viewpoint. Our research indicates that rapid rises in premium costs typically cause consumers to shop around and switch policies in more significant numbers. By contrast, when market forces keep premiums in check, we often see more stability in renewal behaviour.
Since many insurers have already “priced in” the new Ogden rate, the resulting premium stability may mean less impetus for consumers to seek an alternative provider. That might reduce switching levels—at least for a period. Naturally, there is a balance to be struck: while stable premiums can be viewed as positive, the competitive landscape must remain robust so that consumers continue to be well-served.
Broader industry pressures and opportunities
Of course, the Ogden rate isn’t the only factor shaping the insurance market today. Regulatory scrutiny—from the FCA’s Consumer Duty to the ongoing attention on discretionary commission models—places additional pressure on insurers to demonstrate fair value and transparent practices. Government interest in driving down the cost of insurance could also reshape how insurers manage their cost structures.
These influences create what could be described as a “deflationary squeeze,” encouraging insurers to find efficiencies and maintain competitive pricing. The new Ogden rate, therefore, serves as a buoy rather than an anchor—giving the industry a bit more latitude to adjust reserves, manage capital, and explore innovative pricing models without the spectre of immediate rate shock.
Longer-term strategic considerations
Whilst the rate change is encouraging for the bottom line, personal injury solicitors and advocates may respond by seeking different avenues to secure optimal client settlements. We should anticipate that, over the coming years, new processes and case strategies might emerge. The industry should stay vigilant and collaborate with legal representatives and policymakers to ensure that new approaches remain fair and balanced.
For those insurers who correctly anticipated this shift in advance, the benefits will likely include higher solvency margins and potentially more competitive premiums, all while creating a sense of stability for consumers. Strategically, the environment is ripe for increased pricing and customer-centric product design innovation—mainly if insurers channel their resources into better understanding driver segments, claim patterns, and shifting consumer expectations.
Conclusion
Although Ogden rate reviews happen infrequently, each announcement can be a bellwether for how the insurance sector recalibrates. This latest change offers a renewed sense of stability and clarity: an opportunity for insurers to optimise technical pricing, enhance solvency, and for consumers to enjoy a more predictable market.
Looking ahead, the pressure to maintain fair prices and excellent service remains high. But the Ogden adjustment—largely anticipated by several forward-thinking brands—could steer us towards a period of steadier premiums, reduced shopping around, and, ultimately, a more balanced insurance ecosystem. Now is the time for insurers to convert this respite into a long-term strategic advantage, delivering transparency, value, and trust to their customers.
Stay ahead of market shifts with Daily Price Benchmarking...
As insurers navigate evolving market forces like the Ogden rate adjustment, having access to up-to-date, accurate pricing intelligence is more critical than ever. Our Daily Price Benchmarking solution helps insurers track competitive pricing movements in near real-time, empowering smarter pricing decisions and proactive strategy adjustments.
Explore how our Daily Price Benchmarking solution can give you the insights you need to maintain a competitive edge.
Comment . . .
Submit a comment