Analysis of 6,868 insurance quotes for November reveals 17-19 year olds face a median £2,172 penalty for choosing traditional insurance over telematics – effectively removing choice from the equation, with 83% finding telematics their only affordable option.
"Insurers have weaponised pricing to create a captive audience, then wonder why adoption collapses after age 25," says Ian Hughes, CEO of Consumer Intelligence. "They're not building a customer base – they're creating a generation of connected-insurance sceptics."
The Data Reveals a Broken Trajectory
Consumer Intelligence's research exposes how forced adoption becomes lifetime resistance:
- Ages 17-19: 83% find telematics cheaper, with median savings of £2,172 (116% difference)
- Ages 25-29: Adoption drops to 51% as drivers escape with their no-claims discount
- Ages 35-39: Just 25% engage – the refugees don't return voluntarily
- Ages 50+: Only 15-20% consider telematics, despite potential savings of £160-230 when suitable
"The industry is training an entire generation to hate the technology it needs them to embrace for usage-based and connected insurance products in the future," adds Hughes.
The Recognition Gap
Consumer Intelligence's customer research identifies three drivers of voluntary telematics adoption that insurers consistently miss:
- Recognition – Customers want acknowledgment they're already good drivers
- Personalisation – Individual assessment, not demographic bucketing
- Control – Influence over their outcomes and how they're measured
"Insurers think they're selling clever technology. Customers hear 'we don't trust you.' That fundamental miscommunication is costing young drivers thousands and threatening innovation adoption for decades to come."
The Opportunity: From Refugees to Advocates
Consumer Intelligence proposes a fundamental shift in approach:
- Reframe Year One: Position telematics as a "Recognised Driver Journey" – a fast-track to trusted status, not probation
- Change the Language: Replace "we monitor" with "you demonstrate"
- Provide Real Control: Let customers choose what aspects of driving they want to showcase
- Create Lasting Value: Offer permanent recognition status that follows them even if they switch insurers
"Insurers need to stop selling surveillance and start selling recognition," says Hughes. "Our research shows customers who feel recognised and in control have three times higher voluntary adoption rates. The industry is literally explaining its way out of billions in future premiums."
About the Data
Consumer Intelligence analysed 6,868 motor insurance risks during November 2024, comparing telematics and non-telematics pricing across all age groups. The company's quarterly insurance behaviour tracker surveys 2,000 consumers on their attitudes toward connected insurance products.