Motor insurance brands have two opposing views of the way that consumers pay for their insurance, which creates a distortion when it comes to competitive pricing, new research from Consumer Intelligence reveals. Consumers who choose to select monthly payment as their payment preference will be presented with a different set of top ten brands than those who choose to pay annually.

In June, Consumer Intelligence tested which brands were most competitive on price comparison websites by tabulating and comparing how often they occupied a market position between ranks one to five. One hundred and twelve different tests were used to perform this research. For people who preferred to pay annually: Hastings Essential, Churchill, and Privilege all ranked in the top three for most competitive brands. The rest of the top ten were similarly established and respected.

However, when we surveyed the same websites selecting a monthly payment preference, Swinton came out on top for ranks one to five on all four. Hastings Essential was the only other brand to make it into the top three for Compare the Market, Confused, GoCompare and MoneySuperMarket. Autonet, Right Choice, Sure Thing and Privilege also made a competitive appearance. 

The market overview that's needed

The difference is stark. As a rough rule of thumb, when annual payment preference is selected direct insurers do better. When monthly payment preference is chosen, however, it's brokers who win out.

Thanks to our research, Consumer Intelligence has the market overview that's needed to see what’s going on from the eyes of the consumer, and why things look the way they do.

These findings affect everything in the way that pricing is optimised out for both direct insurers, brokers and underlying risk carriers.


If you would like to know what this means for you, how we are responding to it, and what the wider influence might be on your book, then contact us today.

Contact Us

Submit a comment

You may also like

Soaring Insurance Costs Hit "White Van Man" Hardest
Soaring Insurance Costs Hit "White Van Man" Hardest
15 May, 2017

We can reveal today that our research suggests average best-buy prices for van insurance have soared by 9.7% in the past...

Future Of Insurance: A Merging Of Multiple Trends
Future Of Insurance: A Merging Of Multiple Trends
7 March, 2019

One of Consumer Intelligence’s specialist areas is helping insurance brands understand how changes in the industry and c...

Insurance Premium Tax Rise Adds Up To £35 A Year To Motor Insurance
Insurance Premium Tax Rise Adds Up To £35 A Year To Motor Insurance
23 November, 2016

Please see below reaction from insurance market experts Consumer Intelligence to the third rise in Insurance Premium Tax...