annual car insurance bill

  • Older drivers change motor insurer every three-and-a-half years on average
  • But one in seven have not moved for nine years or more


Over-65s can cut their annual car insurance bill by nearly a third by switching to the most competitive insurers, new analysis1 from insurance market research experts Consumer Intelligence shows.


Its unique analysis of more than 14,000 insurance quotes shows the average bill for over-65s is £477 from the most competitive insurers but around £685 for all insurers – a difference of 30% or £208 a year.


Consumer Intelligence’s data highlights how older drivers regularly move insurers – on average they stick with the same insurer for 3.7 years and 44% move every two years. They pay lower average bills as well – the top five average premium for all motorists is £712 compared with £477 for over-65s.


But one in seven over-65s have not moved insurer for nine-plus years and are risking paying over the odds, Consumer Intelligence says


John Blevins, Consumer Intelligence pricing expert said: “Car insurance for over-65s is as competitive as the rest of the market despite claims that older drivers are often penalised for their loyalty.

“In fact, average bills for over-65s are around a third lower than for all motorists and over-65s regularly shop with more than two out of five moving insurer every two years.

“However just as in the rest of the car market those who do not regularly review their car insurance will pay higher bills and it pays to shop around and switch.”

The table below shows how average annual car insurance bills for the over-65s have changed since 2014.



























Consumer Intelligence’s data shows average tenure for over-65s – how long customers stay with insurers – has been relatively constant since 2009 when it first recorded figures. The highest has been 4.4 years and the lowest is 3.2 years.


Optimise your car insurance pricing strategy 

Download our Car Insurance Price Index to gain insight into market movements, benchmark the major car insurance brands and help you understand the data behind the results. 






Notes to Editors
1 Consumer Intelligence analysis of more than 14,000 insurance premium quotes for drivers aged 65-plus between 2014 and April 2018

For further information, please contact:


Catherine Carey
PR & Communications Manager

Consumer Intelligence
07823 790453




Post a comment . . .

Submit a comment

You may also like

Home Insurance Costs Fall But Price Rises Could Be Coming
Home Insurance Costs Fall But Price Rises Could Be Coming
3 December, 2018

Average bills drop 0.4% in a year to £137 but edge up in the past three months Prices are falling fastest in Wales and t...

Brexit Uncertainty Could Drive Continued Car Insurance Price Rises
Brexit Uncertainty Could Drive Continued Car Insurance Price Rises
21 March, 2019

  Average motor premiums drop 6.7% in a year but are now rising Brexit uncertainty could be a driver behind a recent upt...

Car Insurance Premiums Go Into Reverse
Car Insurance Premiums Go Into Reverse
28 June, 2018

Average prices drop 5.5% in year to £712 Under-25s are the biggest winners with a 11.9% cut in bills